Ancient hydrogen and magma ocean offer clues about Earth's origins

By willowt // 2025-04-21

Mastodon

Parler

Gab

Copy

Earth’s water may have originated from its own hydrogen-rich building blocks — not just from asteroids — challenging the long-held theory that water was delivered extraterrestrially. Research suggests hydrogen in early Earth materials could have naturally formed water.
A persistent primordial magma ocean beneath Earth’s mantle likely shaped the planet’s geology, forming dense iron-rich melt layers near the core. This ancient structure may still influence heat exchange and tectonic activity today.
Analysis of rare meteorites (enstatite chondrites) revealed high hydrogen levels, supporting the idea that Earth was "hydrated from birth." However, debate remains over potential contamination of the meteorite samples.
Combined findings suggest Earth's water arose from both internal hydrogen and deep-magma dynamics, implying a collaboration between planetary formation and geologic processes rather than reliance on external water delivery.
These discoveries redefine planetary science, offering insights into habitability on Earth and beyond. Similar processes could apply to other rocky planets, guiding the search for water and life in the universe.

New research from international teams of planetary scientists has upended long-held assumptions about Earth’s early history, revealing that the planet may have been primed for water long before asteroids delivered it — or produced it from within a vast magma ocean. Studies published in Nature and Icarus last month propose that hydrogen from Earth’s own composition and remnants of a primordial magma ocean deep in the mantle could rewrite the understanding of how Earth became habitable. Led by researchers at the University of Oxford and York University, the findings suggest that Earth’s water originated not just from asteroid collisions but also from its own hydrogen-rich building blocks, while a persistent magma layer under Earth’s core shaped its geology from within. These dual discoveries have profound implications for planetary science, geology and the search for life beyond Earth.

Magma ocean remnants shape Earth’s internal dynamics

Charles-Édouard Boukaré, a planetary physicist at York University, and colleagues have unveiled new evidence of an ancient ocean of magma lurking beneath your feet. Published in Nature on March 26, their model demonstrates that Earth’s mantle, the thick layer between its core and crust, must have formed a basal magma ocean within its first few hundred million years of existence. This molten layer, formed as the planet cooled and crystallized, likely persists today as large low-shear velocity provinces (LLVPs), deep-seated mantle “blobs” detected through seismic waves. The researchers’ simulations show that as Earth solidified, dense iron oxide-rich melts sank and pooled near the core, resisting buoyancy due to their composition. “Regardless of where solidification began,” Boukaré explained, “the magma ocean formed inevitably.” This structure could still influence modern phenomena like heat exchange between the core and mantle and the positioning of tectonic plates. The findings challenge prior models suggesting Earth’s early layers solidified from the bottom up, instead revealing a more dynamic interplay between melt and solid during its formative stages.

Meteorites offer a hydrogen “time capsule” challenging water’s origin

Meanwhile, a study led by University of Oxford doctoral candidate Tom Barrett, published in Icarus on April 16, analyzes enstatite chondrites — rare meteorites resembling early Earth — to question where Earth’s water came from. Using X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure (XANES) spectroscopy at a particle accelerator, the team detected tenfold higher hydrogen levels in a meteorite’s sulfur compounds than previously estimated. “The discovery of hydrogen in this meteorite means Earth potentially could have been hydrated or wet from its initial formation,” said Barrett. The findings suggest that Earth’s hydrogen, a key component of water, may have been intrinsic to its building blocks rather than delivered by water-rich asteroids. This reinterprets longstanding theories that a “lucky” asteroid bombardment hydrated the planet. However, planetary scientist Matt Genge of Imperial College London urged caution, noting that the meteorite’s long residence on Earth’s surface might have contaminated its hydrogen levels. The Oxford team countered that they accounted for 15% terrestrial contamination, reaffirming their confidence in native hydrogen as the dominant source.

Bridging the gap — hydrogen, magma and Earth’s watery evolution

These studies converge to paint a deeper picture of Earth’s infancy. If the magma ocean persisted, it might have facilitated hydrogen storage or water retention by trapping volatile elements in the mantle. Meanwhile, the meteorite data imply that early Earth’s materials were already hydrogen-rich, fostering water’s formation organically. Taken together, they suggest a world where primordial hydrogen and deep mantle dynamics collaborated to set the stage for life. Historically, scientists debated whether water arrived via comets and asteroids (the “lucky” scenario) or was an inherent part of Earth’s formation. The meteorite study now provides direct evidence for the latter, though external delivery from smaller asteroids might still contribute a minority of Earth’s hydrogen. Meanwhile, the magma study explains how Earth’s deep structure could have stabilized these volatile elements over billions of years, a process potentially seen in other terrestrial planets.

A new blueprint for planetary science

The twin revelations — of a lingering magma ocean underpinning Earth’s geology and hydrogen-rich materials shaping its water — mark a turning point in understanding planetary evolution. By reconciling geochemical signatures and seismic anomalies, researchers now aim to refine models of mantle dynamics and the conditions necessary for life. As Boukaré notes, “the seeds of our planet’s evolution were planted early,” with Earth’s foundational structures dictating its trajectory long before life emerged. Future work may expand these findings to other worlds, exploring whether Mars or Venus harbor similar magma memories or retained hydrogen reservoirs. These discoveries not only illuminate Earth’s past but also electrify the hunt for water — and potentially life — beyond the solar system. Sources include: LiveScience.com Nature.com Yahoo.com